Call us: 289-893-3663

Free Local Delivery on all orders over $75.00

Pizzeria Quality. Made for Home.

Browse

Want to chat?

Call us: 289-893-3663

Social

🍕Whitby’s March Break Pizza Making Challenge

🧑‍⚖️ PIZZACO CONTEST – JUDGE SCORECARD

📝 Instructions

Please score each pizza from 1–10 in each of the 3 categories CREATIVITY | PRESENTATION | EXECUTION
1 = very low, 10 = outstanding.
Total score from all judges will determine the winner.

You’ll notice that some entrants have more than one photo. We always encourage participants to add an extra photo, such as an action or a family shot.  Feel free to let that influence your scoring. 

NEW THIS YEAR

We decided to give entrants the opportunity to name and describe their pizza, which most people did which I think adds to the creative element.

Please try complete by end of day Thursday. Thank you!

CREATIVITY

How unique or original is this pizza idea? Please score each pizza from 1–10. 1 = very low, 10 = outstanding.

Abigail

Pizza Name
Rapunzel’s sunshine inside of a heart

Pizza Description
Thick crust heart-shaped pizza with a pepperoni centre and a pineapple border. Then the special part – the sun from the movie Tangled using bacon as the sunbeams. I love Rapunzel!

Very lowOutstanding

Adam

Pizza Name
The Perfect Pear

Pizza Description
Juicy pear and a drizzle of golden honey meets spicy soppressata, delicate prosciutto and melted provolone for the perfect balance of sweet heat in every bite.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Ashley

Pizza Name
Holy Pepperoni

Pizza Description
Fresh dough, zesty tomato sauce, melty mozzarella, and perfectly crisped pepperoni coming together to create the ultimate slice of comfort

—

Very lowOutstanding

Benson

Pizza Name
The Bailey pepperoni pizza

Pizza Description
Lots of pepperoni, orange and white cheese, very tasty

—

Very lowOutstanding

Collins Family

Pizza Name
I (we) love pizza!!

Pizza Description
Family of 4 with different preferences of toppings – but we love pizza! (I heart pizza written with toppings)

Very lowOutstanding

Natalie

Pizza Name
Pizza “co” pizza

Pizza Description
It has a C and a O made of pepperoni inside the pizza to represent pizza CO.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Presunka Family

Pizza Name
St. Patrick’s Pretty Pizza

Pizza Description
A Leprechaun’s second surprise at the end of the rainbow 🌈 (broccoli, green olives, green peppers and green food coloring with everything else)

Very lowOutstanding

Zachary

Pizza Name
Video games and pizza…the perfect March Break combination!

Pizza Description
I used pepperoni to make a Nintendo Switch controller with orange pepper joysticks and pineapple arrows and green pepper buttons.

Very lowOutstanding

PRESENTATION

How visually appealing is the pizza? Please score each pizza from 1–10. 1 = very low, 10 = outstanding.

Abigail

Pizza Name
Rapunzel’s sunshine inside of a heart

Pizza Description
Thick crust heart-shaped pizza with a pepperoni centre and a pineapple border. Then the special part – the sun from the movie Tangled using bacon as the sunbeams. I love Rapunzel!

Very lowOutstanding

Adam

Pizza Name
The Perfect Pear

Pizza Description
Juicy pear and a drizzle of golden honey meets spicy soppressata, delicate prosciutto and melted provolone for the perfect balance of sweet heat in every bite.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Ashley

Pizza Name
Holy Pepperoni

Pizza Description
Fresh dough, zesty tomato sauce, melty mozzarella, and perfectly crisped pepperoni coming together to create the ultimate slice of comfort

—

Very lowOutstanding

Benson

Pizza Name
The Bailey pepperoni pizza

Pizza Description
Lots of pepperoni, orange and white cheese, very tasty

—

Very lowOutstanding

Collins Family

Pizza Name
The Bailey pepperoni pizza

Pizza Description
Lots of pepperoni, orange and white cheese, very tasty

Very lowOutstanding

Natalie

Pizza Name
Pizza “co” pizza

Pizza Description
It has a C and a O made of pepperoni inside the pizza to represent pizza CO.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Presunka Family

Pizza Name
St. Patrick’s Pretty Pizza

Pizza Description
A Leprechaun’s second surprise at the end of the rainbow 🌈 (broccoli, green olives, green peppers and green food coloring with everything else)

Very lowOutstanding

Zachary

Pizza Name
Video games and pizza…the perfect March Break combination!

Pizza Description
I used pepperoni to make a Nintendo Switch controller with orange pepper joysticks and pineapple arrows and green pepper buttons.

Very lowOutstanding

EXECUTION

How well was the pizza made? (toppings, balance, effort) Please score each pizza from 1–10. 1 = very low, 10 = outstanding.

Abigail

Pizza Name
Rapunzel’s sunshine inside of a heart

Pizza Description
Thick crust heart-shaped pizza with a pepperoni centre and a pineapple border. Then the special part – the sun from the movie Tangled using bacon as the sunbeams. I love Rapunzel!

Very lowOutstanding

Adam

Pizza Name
The Perfect Pear

Pizza Description
Juicy pear and a drizzle of golden honey meets spicy soppressata, delicate prosciutto and melted provolone for the perfect balance of sweet heat in every bite.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Ashley

Pizza Name
Holy Pepperoni

Pizza Description
Fresh dough, zesty tomato sauce, melty mozzarella, and perfectly crisped pepperoni coming together to create the ultimate slice of comfort

—

Very lowOutstanding

Benson

Pizza Name
The Bailey pepperoni pizza

Pizza Description
Lots of pepperoni, orange and white cheese, very tasty

—

Very lowOutstanding

Collins Family

Pizza Name
The Bailey pepperoni pizza

Pizza Description
Lots of pepperoni, orange and white cheese, very tasty

Very lowOutstanding

Natalie

Pizza Name
Pizza “co” pizza

Pizza Description
It has a C and a O made of pepperoni inside the pizza to represent pizza CO.

—

Very lowOutstanding

Presunka Family

Pizza Name
St. Patrick’s Pretty Pizza

Pizza Description
A Leprechaun’s second surprise at the end of the rainbow 🌈 (broccoli, green olives, green peppers and green food coloring with everything else)

Very lowOutstanding

Zachary

Pizza Name
Video games and pizza…the perfect March Break combination!

Pizza Description
I used pepperoni to make a Nintendo Switch controller with orange pepper joysticks and pineapple arrows and green pepper buttons.

Very lowOutstanding

Thank you once again for Participating!

Feel free to say a few words about the contest or the entries. If you have a personal favourite, one that tops them all, please mention it here.

👀 SPECIAL GUEST JUDGES 👀

We’ve invited special community judges to help select our winners.

Stay tuned — judge announcements coming soon.

Mayor Elizabeth Roy - Judge

Elizabeth Roy was first elected to Whitby Council in 2006 and is serving her first term as mayor. She served as west ward councillor from 2006 to 2014, and was then elected as a regional councillor in 2014 and 2018.

Terry Johnston - Judge

Terry Johnston is a long-time morning show host on CKDO Radio in Oshawa since 1992 and famously known as the voice of the Oshawa Generals since 2007

Lindsey Press - Judge

Lindsey is a local content creator and manages the Instagram account, @Hey_Kidz_Let’s Eat, Durham Region’s go-to resource for families seeking deals, perks, and promos when dining out!
Free Local Delivery

On all orders above $75

Proudly Local

Crafted in Whitby and serving our community with every box.

100% Secure Checkout

Visa / MasterCard / Amex / Etransfer